Pixel Tag and SmartTag3 Cost the Same—Your Phone Should Pick the Winner
Google’s Pixel Tag and Samsung’s Galaxy SmartTag3 now cost exactly the same in the United States: $29.99 for one tracker or $99.99 for a four-pack. That makes the price comparison easy. The harder part is noticing that these two tags belong to different finding systems, and buying the wrong one can leave you without the features that justify the purchase.
For most people, the sensible choice is not the tag with the longest specification list. It is the tag that fits the phones already used by the household. Pixel Tag works with Android phones running Android 9 or later through Google’s Find Hub. SmartTag3 requires the SmartThings app and supports Galaxy phones and tablets on Android 12 or later, plus iPhones on iOS 17 or later—but Samsung reserves several useful features for Galaxy devices.
Pixel Tag is the safer cross-brand Android purchase
Pixel Tag is Google’s first own-brand item tracker. Setup starts by pulling the battery tab and bringing the tag near a compatible Android phone. Fast Pair handles the connection, and the tag then appears in the Find Hub app. Owners can share it with as many as 10 people, which is practical for car keys, checked luggage or a bag used by several family members.
When the tag is nearby, Find Hub can make it ring. Pixel Tag also contains ultra-wideband hardware and Bluetooth Channel Sounding for visual direction and distance guidance on compatible phones. Those last three words matter: an Android 9 phone can meet the basic software requirement without containing the radio hardware needed for the most precise search experience.
When the item is farther away, Google says Find Hub can draw on a network of more than one billion Android devices to report its location. That does not turn the tag into a GPS tracker with its own cellular connection. A location update still depends on another participating device passing close enough to detect it.
The physical design is thin enough for a wallet at 1.8 by 1.1 by 0.2 inches. It weighs 0.4 ounces with its battery and carries an IP67 rating, which covers dust and immersion in up to one meter of fresh water for as long as 30 minutes under test conditions. Its CR2032 battery is user-replaceable and rated to last more than a year.
SmartTag3 rewards a recent Galaxy phone
Samsung’s tracker has the stronger battery claim. Its replaceable CR2032 cell is rated for up to 550 days in regular use or 790 days in Power Saving Mode. Power Saving Mode is not free extra runtime, however: Samsung says it disables features including Compass View, ringtone settings and volume controls while retaining basic Bluetooth finding.
Compass View can show distance and direction on Galaxy devices that support ultra-wideband or Bluetooth 6.0 Channel Sounding. Samsung lists UWB reach of up to 20 meters and Channel Sounding reach of up to 60 meters under line-of-sight conditions; walls, nearby electronics and other obstructions can reduce those figures. Ordinary Bluetooth Low Energy communication is rated for up to 120 meters in ideal conditions.
SmartTag3 can also trigger SmartThings routines with its button, ring a linked phone or tablet, and show up to seven days of location history. Its square body measures 31 by 31 by 8.2 millimeters, weighs 9.15 grams and is rated IP67. Unlike Pixel Tag, it is offered in black and white.
Samsung’s new iPhone compatibility needs a careful reading. An iPhone running iOS 17 or later can join a SmartThings family and use supported shared-tracking functions, but Compass View, Ring Phone and Left Behind Alert are not available on iOS. Buying SmartTag3 for an iPhone therefore does not produce the same experience as pairing it with a recent Galaxy phone.
Choose the network before the hardware
For a household with Pixels, Motorolas or a mix of Android brands, Pixel Tag is the cleaner choice because the tag remains useful after switching between Android manufacturers. A Galaxy household gets more from SmartTag3: longer claimed battery life, SmartThings routines and richer history, provided the phones support the necessary radios.
Before buying a four-pack, check the exact phone model rather than the Android or iOS version alone. Software compatibility gets the tag paired; UWB or Channel Sounding support determines whether nearby searches include directional guidance. Also decide which family members need access, because sharing across different finding networks is not interchangeable.
Neither tracker should be treated as a live theft-recovery device. Both depend on nearby phones, network participation and environmental conditions. For keys and bags, though, the decision is unusually clear: spend the same $29.99 on the tracker designed around the phone you already carry.

0 Comments